-
NVIDIA opposes Nazemian attempt to amend the complaint
Read more: NVIDIA opposes Nazemian attempt to amend the complaintNVIDIA opposes Nazemian plaintiffs’ attempt to amend the complaint to expand the allegations related to NVIDIA’s use of shadow libraries, as well as vicarious and contributory infringement claims. (Nazemian himself wants to voluntarily drop out of the case, leaving Dubus.) Excerpts from NVIDIA’s Brief Related Stories DOWNLOAD NVIDIA’S BRIEF
-
Nazemian seeks to amend complaint v. NVIDIA to add use of more shadow libraries & pirated books
Read more: Nazemian seeks to amend complaint v. NVIDIA to add use of more shadow libraries & pirated booksThe ripple effect from Judge Alsup’s ruling on summary judgment in Bartz v. Anthropic continues. Yet another plaintiff is copying what I call the Shadow Library Strategy and attempting to add a separate claim of copyright infringement based on the allegation that the defendant AI company downloaded and used additional shadow libraries containing pirated books.…
-
Judge Tigar amends scheduling order in Nazemian v. NVIDIA
Read more: Judge Tigar amends scheduling order in Nazemian v. NVIDIAJudge Tigar has granted the Nazemian plaintiffs’ motion to amend the scheduling order, extending most of the deadlines another month. Replies to summary judgment motions won’t be due until Dec. 4, 2026. This does not really affect the order of judges who will have the next chance to decide fair use in AI training, which…
-
NVIDIA opposes Nazemian’s motion to amend scheduling order
Read more: NVIDIA opposes Nazemian’s motion to amend scheduling orderNVIDIA filed its opposition to the plaintiff Nazemian’s motion to amend the scheduling order for more time. DOWNLOAD THE BRIEF OF NVIDIA
-
Magistrate Judge Sallie Kim clarifies Nazemian’s discovery of The Pile dataset from NVIDIA
Read more: Magistrate Judge Sallie Kim clarifies Nazemian’s discovery of The Pile dataset from NVIDIAOn October 2, 2025, Magistrate Judge Sallie Kim clarified the scope of discovery related to the Pile dataset allowed. Judge Kim had previously allowed: “the motion to compel discovery regarding the use of The Pile to train datasets in the Nemo Megatron family beyond the four large language models specifically named in the Complaint.” Judge…
-
Judge Tigar rejects Nazemian’s attempt to get discovery of datasets beyond Complaint
Read more: Judge Tigar rejects Nazemian’s attempt to get discovery of datasets beyond ComplaintJudge Tigar upheld Magistrate Judge Sallie Kim’s ruling that denied Nazemian’s request to discover datasets from NVIDIA beyond the ones stated in the Complaint. Related Stories
-
NVIDIA files opposition to Nazemian’s attempt to reverse Magistrate Judge’s decision rejecting discovery of datasets outside of Complaint
Read more: NVIDIA files opposition to Nazemian’s attempt to reverse Magistrate Judge’s decision rejecting discovery of datasets outside of ComplaintNVIDIA just filed its opposition in response to Nazemian’s motion to reverse Magistrate Judge Sallie Kim’s denial of the plaintiffs’ motion to compel discovery of other datasets (from “shadow libraries”) not included in the Complaint.
-
Judge Tigar denies Joseph Saveri, others bid for interim co-lead counsel in suit v. NVIDIA
Read more: Judge Tigar denies Joseph Saveri, others bid for interim co-lead counsel in suit v. NVIDIAJudge Tigar ruled there was no demonstrated need to appoint interim co-lead class counsel in the consolidated cases Nazemian and Dubus versus NVIDIA.
-
NVIDA seeks to consolidate Nazemian, Dubus suits
Read more: NVIDA seeks to consolidate Nazemian, Dubus suitsNVIDIA has filed a motion to consolidate the two copyright suits filed by Nazemian and Dubus, who oppose the motion for some reason. I expect Judge Tigar to grant this motion.
-
Lawyers from Susman Godrey added to represent book authors in Nazemian v. NVIDIA, In re Mosiac LLM Litigation
Read more: Lawyers from Susman Godrey added to represent book authors in Nazemian v. NVIDIA, In re Mosiac LLM LitigationSeven lawyers from Susman Godfrey, the same firm representing the New York Times in its lawsuit against OpenAI and Microsoft, have just been added to represent the plaintiff book authors in two different lawsuits: Nazemian v. NVIDIA and In re Mosaic LLM Litigation. It’s unclear whether the Susman Godfrey lawyers will take the lead for…