Chat GPT Is Eating the World

Category: Bartz v. Anthropic

Bartz adds class action specialist Jallé H. Dafa to legal team

The Bartz book authors have added Jallé H. Dafa of Lieff Cabraser to their legal team in anticipation of the Dec. 1st trial. Dafa is a partner in the San Francisco office and specializes in class-action litigation. Dafa graduated from Berkeley Law and clerked for Judge Corley in the Northern District of California and Judge…
Read more: Bartz adds class action specialist Jallé H. Dafa to legal team
Bartz seeks to compel Anthropic to produce financial statements, revenue projections, and minutes of Board of Directors

The Bartz book authors, buoyed by Judge Alsup’s certification of a class action, are now asking the Judge to compel Anthropic to produce Board of Directors’ minutes related to “Concern or Relate to Your training data; Your intention to commercialize, monetize, or productize Your LLMs; or projections regarding revenues or profits for particular products or…
Read more: Bartz seeks to compel Anthropic to produce financial statements, revenue projections, and minutes of Board of Directors
Claude agrees with ChatGPT: Anthropic faces very high probability of statutory damages over $1 billion

We ran the same Monte Carlo simulation using largely the same assumptions as we did with ChatGPT, although we did specify with Claude 6 million as the max for works (even though it can theoretically be some number under 7 million). The results, not surprisingly, nearly the same. ChatGPT probabilities of damages amount in Anthropic…
Read more: Claude agrees with ChatGPT: Anthropic faces very high probability of statutory damages over $1 billion
Facing business-ending liability, Anthropic adds another attorney to defense team

Anthropic is in a legal fight for its very existence. In a code red moment, Anthropic hired 2 new law firms and 13 new trial attorneys to defend the company in 2 copyright lawsuits. The more dire situation is the class action of book authors filed by Bartz. After Judge Alsup certified a class of…
Read more: Facing business-ending liability, Anthropic adds another attorney to defense team
Will Anthropic suffer “Napster-like” fate? We asked ChatGPT.

More and more it looks like December 1, 2025 will be a day of reckoning for Anthropic. After Judge Alsup certified a class action of authors’ whose books were downloaded by Anthropic in 2 shadow libraries of pirated books (Library Genesis and PiLiMi), and after the judge ruled that such downloading and storage by Anthropic…
Read more: Will Anthropic suffer “Napster-like” fate? We asked ChatGPT.
Will a jury in SF decide Anthropic’s business fate? Most likely yes.

September 1 and December 1, 2025. These dates may determine Anthropic’s business fate. And, by business fate, I mean Anthropic’s continued existence. Some readers may think I’m being hyperbolic. I wish I were. But the grim reality is that Anthropic now faces a class action (subject to the plaintiffs’ meeting the condition of preparing a…
Read more: Will a jury in SF decide Anthropic’s business fate? Most likely yes.
Anthropic faces potential business-ending liability in statutory damages after Judge Alsup certifies class action by Bartz

In practical terms, what class certification means is that Anthropic faces at least the potential for business-ending liability. It all depends on the number of works within the class (yet to be determined by the plaintiffs in compiling its list, as Judge Alsup instructed). But it also depends on the figure the jury picks within…
Read more: Anthropic faces potential business-ending liability in statutory damages after Judge Alsup certifies class action by Bartz
Anthropic files motion to seek leave to file interlocutory appeal of Judge Alsup’s partial summary judgment

Here’s the entry on the docket: ENTRY FILED DESCRIPTION 241 Jul. 14, 2025 MOTION for Leave to Appeal Pursuant to 28 USC 1292(b), or in the Alternative, For Leave to Move for Reconsideration filed by Anthropic PBC. Motion Hearing set for 8/28/2025 08:00 AM in San Francisco, Courtroom 12, 19th Floor before Judge William Alsup.…
Read more: Anthropic files motion to seek leave to file interlocutory appeal of Judge Alsup’s partial summary judgment
Three judges made fair use rulings re: AI training. They appear torn.

With this week’s blockbuster rulings in Bartz v. Anthropic and Kadrey v. Meta, we now have decisions by three federal judges on the question whether the use of copyrighted works to train AI models that do not produce allegedly infringing outputs when deployed is a fair use. This is a novel question of law, so…
Read more: Three judges made fair use rulings re: AI training. They appear torn.
More on Judge Alsup’s Solomonic decision finding fair use and infringement in Bartz v. Anthropic

Judge William Alsup issued the first decision on fair use and infringement in a generative AI case, Bartz v. Anthropic. It was a split decision: (1) copies used to train Anthropic’s AI model were “exceedingly transformative” and fair uses to develop a technology “among the most transformative many of us will see in our lifetimes,”…
Read more: More on Judge Alsup’s Solomonic decision finding fair use and infringement in Bartz v. Anthropic